Bob just sent me a link to a really cool demo of an Ajax site in action: ajaxWrite.com. At first glance, this is a really cool demo of the power of Ajax (VERY cool actually). But the plot thickens. It turns out the man behind all this is none other than Michael Robertson (if you view source from Firefox, you’ll see that link is hosting this in a frame that goes back to the www.michaelrobertson.com TLD). Great, there’s an agenda behind what would otherwise be a really cool Ajax enabled app.
I am pretty sure Robertson is a complete idiot.
I also found this link where Robertson explains his ideas surrounding ajaxWriter, which I will promptly dissect here (at a very high level, I’ll leave the rest of it as an exercise for the reader…it’s almost comical actually).
And oh yeah, it was FREE so consumers didn't have to pay $499 for Microsoft Office.
Word costs $229 USD, and the Word Viewer is free.
Anytime you need a word processor, need to open a .doc file or edit a .doc file, simply point your Firefox browser at ajaxWrite.com and in seconds a full-featured program will be loaded. For 90 percent of the people in the world, the need to buy Microsoft Word just vanished. This won't make Microsoft happy, but software users should be very excited that software just got cheaper, immediate and modern.
If by seconds he means 30+, then sure…it’s seconds. Word opens up in < 5 seconds on my machine. Full featured? Hardly…it’s nothing more than a glorified WordPad (which is free on Windows machines, and there are plenty of free desktop apps for Mac/*nix that can read .doc formats). But he also contradicts himself: “Point your Firefox browser at ajaxWrite…90% of the people in the world, the need to buy Microsoft Word just vanished.” 90% of the users of Word are business users, and simply don’t have the ability to install Firefox, and even so they would never use a (crippled) web based version to get their work done, and nor would managers allow it. Not to mention Firefox has < 10% market share at this point. So feasibly (assuming all 10% of the Firefox userbase switched to ajaxWriter) only 10% marketshare could be achieved. Microsoft not happy? I’m sure they could care less…Linspire was in all practical terms a failure in their initial goal to replace Windows (see my letter to Robertson above). And there is nothing “modern” about this implementation of an online Word.
These programs look and operate much like their traditional software cousins, but are cross-platform, loaded dynamically, and are available to users at no charge. I'm convinced if you try a few of these products you will understand how the software business will fundamentally change.
This guy just simply doesn’t get the software business, or any business for that matter. No wonder he’s company-hopped his entire career. There is absolutely nothing about ajaxWriter that will “fundamentally” change anything, except to showcase the power of Ajax. Plus it’s web based, so even if (hypothetically) they were able to make inroads into businesses, what happens when the service is goes down/becomes unavailable? You then have employees sitting on their hands doing nothing, and businesses are losing money. The business model (if you can even call it that) behind this is flawed in oh so many ways.
The impact of this shift in how software is delivered to users cannot be understated. First and foremost, we're blowing up the economic model that companies like Microsoft and Adobe have built their empires around - selling packaged software for big dollar amounts.
Yet people keep buying these packages even though there are plenty of free alternatives to choose from. I don’t understand why this guy keeps choosing to go down paths others have already been down, and have failed at. I’m not saying I disagree with the premise behind the ventures he’s done, but history has proven most of these attempts to be fruitless and irrelevant in the long run (Linspire anyone?). Microsoft/Adobe’s economic model aren’t going anywhere anytime soon, especially from some fledgling attempt like this.
Rather than living with a software program for 3 years until a new version is released, these programs are constantly being updated with features, bug fixes and security enhancements…
Great, so there is the potential that every time I visit ajaxWrite that I could be greeted with a somewhat different interface and new features? That’ll go over real well with users (who, for the most part, like consistency). Will I have the option to turn some of these so called “features” off if I want to? Will it be customizable? Etc.
I encourage you to try ajaxWrite.com from Firefox 1.5, or newer, and experience the future of software firsthand.
He sure does seem to be pushing Firefox pretty hard. It’s unbelievable that he’s enforcing browser lock-in…by this vein he’s no better than the software companies he’s out to compete with; he’s a hypocrite. Open it up to IE and he might get at least a couple of people using this service, but certainly not the number of people he has in mind. The experience just isn’t that great.
I’m not saying there isn’t a place for software like this, but the agenda behind it makes me sick to my stomach. He just can’t accept defeat (again, Linspire anyone?), and it’s quite obvious where his intentions are…this whole “for the people” crap is nothing more than a thin veil for someone with a vendetta. Why can’t he just give up and do something useful for a change. If Linspire wasn’t a big enough flop, this most certainly will be (from a business standpoint at least)…this will be a classic example of death by agenda.
Sidenote: I’m putting on the tin foil hat for a minute. Trying to view the source of ajaxWriter (ajax is just javascript, so the “secret sauce” is all right there in the open) was a bit more difficult than other pages. Right click? No option to view source. Try to enable the standard FF menus in the ajaxWriter window? Nope, no option. Ctrl-Shift-U? Yep, that works. I wonder if any of that was intentional though…if he’s trying to keep the source from prying eyes. Hmmm. Ok, tin foil hat off.



No comments yet