Shannon brings up some excellent points in his comment to my previous post:
“If you won't tell us how the scammers are screwing people, please tell us how to prevent it from happening to us.
Why are you being urged to help protect the scammer's secret methods and who is asking you to do this?”
I’ve been so caught up in this ordeal for the past couple of days that when I finally did have time to post about it I didn’t address exactly what happened. They are screwing us by coming up with new and improved ways to…well, screw us (I will give details later in this post about what (I think) happened). When the Nigerian scam first came out, it preyed on normal every day people, and was one of the first of it’s kind in that it preyed on peoples’ belief that everyone on the internet are good honest people. God knows how many people fell for it, but the fact that it’s still even around must mean that it’s still working, even after it’s been publicized all over the internet. Even my Grandmother knows about it. Of course it probably doesn’t work nearly as good as it used to, but eBay has made it all but impossible for it to work because they changed the system itself.
As the internet has gotten more mature (and for the most part, relatively safe) the scammers have to get more creative and utilize more social engineering techniques other than praying on their “good conscious nature,” i.e. they have to extract information via other avenues, but still keep it within the confines of the system itself, in this case eBay. I was scammed through a 100% legit purchase that took place within the eBay sub-system where everything is tracked and kept tidy and whatnot. Frequent eBayers (like those who make a living from it) probably would’ve seen the scam; folks such as myself who buy somewhat frequently but sell very infrequently (I’ve sold 10, maybe 12 items) are easier targets, and I’m sure the scammers look for this as the patrol people’s wares. Always go for the novice.
More specifically, I got caught off-guard by a variant of the “second chance offer” scam. My goods didn’t sell, I got a second chance offer notice, clicked the confirmation process and was done with it. A normal transaction like I’ve done plenty of times before. Except for one thing…there have been a phishing email included somewhere in the process that I missed and clicked through anyways. And of course I have no idea where it is. Which is why I hate to speculate, it could’ve been something else, which is what we’re working on (and I hate jumping to conclusions…I’m a man of science so I require empirical evidence, but I also subscribe to Occam’s Razor).
But if I had to speculate, I’d say that there are a new (or hell, maybe even not so knew…I don’t subscribe to scammers digest) group of scammers who are willing to actually take the risk of paying for an item in order to try to get financial information out of the user, so that it all looks completely legit on the surface. Again, pure speculation, but:
They go for novices (it’s very easy to obtain a user’s buying/selling history from eBay just by scanning through auctions). Seasoned eBayers scour the forums for new scam information. Well they make a lot more money off of eBay sales than I do, so they can devote that kind of time. I’d never even heard of a second chance offer until a couple of weeks ago.
They go for low priced items that seem overpriced (this way they don’t take too much of a hit if they buy the item but get “caught” or whatever), which increases their chance of getting a second chance offer bid into the auction after it closes, which is another process that novice eBayer-ers such as myself aren’t too familiar with.
They seem to work in groups (large groups actually, or it could be automated, who knows) to get a lot of fake auctions up that only they “bid” on and probably just transfer funds to and from their different accounts…but this way they can get their positive feedback rating raised, so that again they look like legit bidders.
And that’ it…I have no idea. If I did, maybe I’d be in the scamming business and not the 1’s and 0’s biz.
To answer his second question, I of course told everyone that I run one of the busiest blogs on the internet (lol, how do they know I don’t ;-) and that I’d do a ton of trash-talking and expose them as frauds or whatever. They didn’t explicitly say don’t, they just said “we’d appreciate it if this information was kept private for now as it may compromise the investigation.” Fair enough, it’s kinda like people who find security holes in software and then immediately publish how to exploit it. Granted this is an entirely different situation, but I could see how eBay would get a little nervous if the exact steps (which we don’t know yet) were published without giving them time to figure out how to prevent it. But most importantly I just want my g/d money back.
So, Jayson’s guide to safe eBaying (yes, I’m sure we all know this, but sometimes even missing just one can be very not good):
Never ever ever ever click on anything in a message from eBay. I don’t care if you can read raw email headers like a madman and trace it back to Meg Whitman herself, don’t click anything! Not in the middle of a transaction, never. It doesn’t matter if it includes your username, your real name, your home address, your blood type I’m pretty sure this is where I goofed.
Never ever ever ever check the “include my email address” in correspondence messages to anyone. Go Google my email username (jaypatrick). Of course that may just be me being a not so savvy net user and not trying to be anonymous, but there is so much crap that can be harvested from any type of personal information. If for some reason you need to communicate via email to a user, set up a junk account and delete it when you’re done. In my case, my eBay username has jaypatrick in it (not once did we communicate outside the eBay system, I do know better than that), so et’ voila.
It’s all about the feedback baby, though in this case this was probably fraudulent as well, i.e. it was done in a circle of accounts. I never sell to less than 10 positives, though now I no longer sell to anyone (see below).
If you suspect anything at all, report it to eBay. Of course if you don’t suspect anything, then this doesn’t work. I certainly had no idea (isn’t that the definition of a scam?).
Any finally, my number one most efficient way to avoid getting duped on eBay: Don’t fucking use it. If you’re a casual seller like me, use Craig’s List or some other (local and free) classifieds based system. No hassle, no fuss, they come pick it up and will always give you cold hard cash for your items if you ask for it (that’s been my experience at least). If they can’t pay cash, there’s a problem in the first place.
I hate eBay. It’s a huge faceless corporation with no identity of its own. I will never do business with them ever again. Double fuck PayPal. They just don’t care…they are willing to take the hit of losing business it would seem. They just don’t give a shit. I’m SO PISSED!
That’s it for now. Help a brotha out if you feel so inclined.



No comments yet