From CNet (full article here):
SAN FRANCISCO--After years of trying to get people to switch to Macs from Intel-based computers, Apple Computer itself has switched.
This confirms my earlier post that Apple is indeed switching from PowerPC to some sort of Intel based platform. What I find amazing is that Apple has been developing for x86 all along per Jobs: “Mac OS X has been leading a secret double life the past five years”…5 years they managed to keep it a secret (though rumors have been flying that this was true)….most impressive. He was actually running the entire keynote on an Intel based Mac: “The CEO showed a demo of the Tiger operating system on an Intel-based machine, saying, "We've been running on an Intel system all morning."” Note that no specific architecture (x86/i64/x64) is mentioned in the article, so that’s still up in the air. My thoughts:
I don’t think Intel will be fabbing a custom chip for Apple. Setting up production for another core is expensive and requires dedicating a whole line at a plant. If Apple couldn't get IBM to keep the PPC up to date, they certainly can't get Intel to make custom processors for them. While they have been developing for x86 all along, using the architecture would be a step backwards for them as their OS is 64bit native; their customers would not accept this.
Apple is first and foremost a hardware company; their OS will only run on Mac branded hardware, even if it is off the shelf processors. How they will implement this remains to be seen…if/when it gets hacked, it could be disastrous for Apple so they’ll really need to cross their t’s and dot their i’s on this one.
This will not affect Microsoft in any way whatsoever…if anything it will help MS as per the article “That doesn't preclude someone from running it on a Mac. They probably will…We won't do anything to preclude that.” I’ve seen some comments on the web where Mac users would dual boot Windows (for games, work stuff)/MacOS (for everything else)…I know I’d be a candidate for this scenario, and MS has already pledged support; “A Microsoft executive said the company would create universal binaries with future versions of Office for the Mac.” This will actually lower their product development costs.
This also won’t have any effect on IBM…someone over there is probably breathing a huge sigh of relief as Jobs is known to be a pretty tough customer, plus the volume of PPC chips is miniscule compared to their other lines. The huge orders coming in from MS (XBox 360), Sony, and Nintendo will more than offset the loss of Apple.
IMO, this will effectively kill Linux on the desktop once and for all. Linux binary compatibility will happen very shortly after the transition, so a machine that runs the *nix folks’ favorite *nix apps and MS Office will finally be a reality. This will also have serious implications on the WINE project as there really won’t be a need for it anymore. LindowsOS (err Linspire) will be the Linux distro hit hardest by this change; I doubt they’ll survive if Apple can get their PC prices more in line with the big 3 (Dell/HP/IBM).
Apple has stated they will start with the Mac Mini/laptops first…I’m not convinced this is a good idea; just switch the whole line at once (unless they have chips sitting on shelves, which is unlikely). Doing it peicemeal will do nothing but further alienate themselves from their users, not to mention stall ISV’s from porting their apps over to the new architecture. No doubt their Mac sales will be way down during the transition; as I mentioned in my previous post, iPod sales will have to carry them (and they will) during the switch.
Jobs announced an emulation tool called “Rosetta” during the keynote: “Apple has a transcoding tool called Rosetta that will allow programs written for PowerPC chips to run on Intel-based machines”. This is what I’m most interested in as PearPC has been working on this for quite some time, I’m also curious about the performance ramifications this entails.
All in all, I think this is a fantastic decision by Apple…everyone wins in the end (which is rare in decisions like this). Maybe it’s actually time for Apple to be a serious contender in the desktop PC realm, if anything they’ve definitely earned this right. I would never switch completely (I make my living by using MS products), but I would definitely dual boot MacOS/Windows, but if they can get the price right, some serious inroads could be made. Kudos to Jobs/Apple, I can’t wait to see where this goes.



No comments yet