Analysts see Java EE dying in an SOA world

From TechTarget (full article here, TheServerSide.com coverage here):

Java Platform, Enterprise Edition (Java EE) is not going to survive as a major standard programming model in the next five years, predicts Richard Monson-Haefel, senior analyst with the Burton Group, and SOA is part of the reason.

…

"In five years, Java EE will be the CORBA of the 21st Century," Monson-Haefel quipped. "People will look at it and say, 'It had its time but nobody uses it any more because it was too complicated.' "

…

"The Java programming language is not threatened here," the Burton analyst said. "I think the Java programming language is going to continue to thrive and be the mainstay for most enterprise development for years to come."

The irony is that I was drafting an article recently about something very similar to this: The Java folks like to laugh at .Net for not having numerous 3rd party frameworks in place to accomplish programming tasks…well we don’t have to, most of what we need is already built into the .Net framework (i.e. JNI = p/invoke and interop, Struts = MVC which is already built into ASP.NET, RMI = .Net Remoting, the list goes on and on). The result of Java having so many 3rd party frameworks is an enormous amount of added complexity, plus fragmentation of the Java platform itself.

It’s not Java’s fault though (and I do agree with the last quote from the article above, Java “the language” isn’t going anywhere)…the core platform was written quite a while back before SOA was even a twinkle in the web’s eye. I personally have nothing against Java (aside from the complexity of developing anything more than a hello world application); but the message has been clear for a while now: Sun needs to re-architect and modernize it. Yes, growing pains are hard…the MS folks all have memories from when Microsoft made [us make] the move from VB/ASP to .Net, but we all survived and are better programmers (and can develop more robust solutions with faster time to market) because of it. Granted .Net learned a lot from Java’s growing pains, but perhaps they can learn a bit from ours in the process as well, we all gain in the end from this.

So, welcome to the club Sun…languages/platforms will always be playing hop-scotch with one another, but again this is a good thing. Do something and raise the bar, much as you did back in the 90’s with Java itself.

No comments yet